The Classic - Eye liner pencil

Disappointing

I’ve used and loved other CT eyeliners but this particular one was waxy and awful. It pulled at the delicate skin around my eyes during application and went on unevenly.

Subtle sparkle

I use this eyeliner daily and have for a while! I love the subtle sparkle and beautiful shade. I’m not sure that it’s the most long lasting but I don’t wear a lot of makeup and like the subtle aspect of it. And it would probably help if I used a primer.

Perfect Brown for Blue Eyes!

I've been looking for a softer brown (not chestnut or brown/black) and this is it! Gorgeous color. Medium maybe even a little reddish. Works well with primer (I have greasy lids so I can't even pretend to try without primer). Love it!

The worst pencil I’ve ever purchased

While I love some Charlotte tilbury items, this pencil is the worst eyeliner pencil I’ve ever purchased. It has to be sharpened with each use and then it breaks every time. It only last 3 weeks because of the constant cheapening and breaking. The brown also has a red tint. Sorry, but it’s true, there are so many other better and less expensive option.

My favorite!

This is my favorite go-to liner. Smudges perfectly. I accidentally bought the gel one and was stuck with that until it was gone. Happy to have this back in my bag! It’s perfect!

soft pencil!

soft pencil, blends easily. perfect brown color . absolutely recommended

Not good.

This was really disappointing. It’s very flaky trying to apply, dry, scratchy and leaves very little payoff. It also has no staying power whatsoever. The photo: top 3 marks are CT with various pressure, the bottom is Urban Decay light pressure. I just wanted to show how pale the payoff is even pressing hard with the CT.

It's honestly a gorgeous color. If you have allergies to animal products of any kind, you will likely get a reaction

Goldilocks of Shimmer Brown Eyeliners

I have been desperate to find a brown liner with a hint of shimmer - some are too sparkly, some have no real glitz, but this one is just right. The color is rich and gorgeous and applies smoothly, smudges well, and lasts great.

So disappointed on this. The color is great but the pencil just doesn’t sharpen. It’s too soft and constantly breaks. I even tried the hacks on you tube but still won’t work. Had to return. So disappointed. It also bleeds and smudges over time.

Skip!

Not good. No pigment or color payoff whatsoever. Will be returning!

Subtle and easy to use

Product goes on so easily, and has a nice sheer medium brown which is just this natural enhancement type of look. I don’t want heavy liner, just a hint of sheer, buildable colour. Will be buying again for sure.