Pillow talk mini push up lashes - travel size mascara

Really Disappointed

I confess that I chose this mascara because it was the only one that didn't have the word "EXTREME" in its name, lol (well, also because CT is generally a good brand, and I have liked some of their other products). Unfortunately, this mascara was messy to apply and clumpy. It was hard to remove the inevitable smudges from my eyelids. It managaed to come off pretty easily from my lashes, however, because it regularly left me with dark circles under my eyes after only a few hours. The color is nice, and I only got a travel size- those are the best two things about this purchase. :(

I love this product it’s sooooooo good

It’s easy to apply and open makes my lashes look so much better than they look naturally

Why all the hate?

Why are people hating on this mascara so much? This was the first charlotte tilbury product I’ve tried and all I can say, is that I am shocked with the results. After curling my lashes, I apply 2-3 layers. At the end of the day, none of the mascara comes off and it hold my lashes up. I get so many compliments a day, and I will 100% repurchase.

!BEST EVER! 🥰

After decades of clumpy mascara, I have found the first that doesn’t clump. BEST MASCARA EVER!

The best natural looking mascara for my lashes!

I got the mini size to try it out and it’s been phenomenal! I have very sparse but long lashes so I was looking for a natural-looking mascara that gives some volume and this was THE ONE. It looks so natural on my lashes but also gives me just the smallest bit of volume! Here’s how I use it: I go in with the bristled side first and do a coat or two, then I use the flat side and push it up into my lashes. Then I comb it out once more with the bristled side. So good, 10/10 recommend!

Not Great

Great applicator but product is awful. Product clumped when putting it on and flaked constantly until it was taken off.

Trash

Raccoon eyes after an hour. Nope! Too expensive to be this bad.

This mascara is very clumpy and smudges easily. The applicator applies the product in clumps on your lashes and there have been a few times that it was so bad that I needed to wash off my eye makeup and start over.

Honestly, I wasn’t impressed! A lot of product comes off the brush and I find myself wiping a lot of it off. I hate when you have to do that. It’s either too much or too little. It does give volume but overall I didn’t care for it.

Mascara dried out too quickly after only one use. It also not good at lengthening and volumizing.

Not terrible, not the best

I have used high end and drugstore mascaras and this one just falls right in the middle. It does give me length and volume, but drugstore doesn’t better for me. For reference, I have straight Asian lashes. The first pic is pillow talk and the second pic is with my L’Oréal mascara

This is my favorite mascara! It has an amazing wand that has absolutely no clumps and it make my lashes look so long and natural!!! It is also very cheap and super affordable!